Should Graduates Look for Jobs in Asia? — 35/42 (5**) [working title — student did not provide one]

2016 HKDSE English Paper 2 · Q3 (Part B) · pages 26–30 + 32 (supplementary sheet) · analysed 12 May 2026
Year: 2016 Part: B Question: Q3 Genre: magazine article (argumentative) Grade band: 5** Marks: 18 + 17 = 35 / 42 Candidate: 2016-002
Question prompt (Q3 — Learning English through Workplace Communication)

Many Hong Kong graduates complain about the lack of employment opportunities in the city. It has been suggested that the graduates who fail to find a job in Hong Kong could look for opportunities in other cities in Asia. Do you support this suggestion?

Write an article for the Young Post explaining your views. Provide an appropriate title for your article. (~400 words)

Show original handwritten pages (5)
Page 27 — opening paragraphs
Page 27 (booklet p.8)
Page 28 — middle of the article
Page 28 (booklet p.9)
Page 29 — benefits argument
Page 29 (booklet p.10)
Page 30 — mutual-benefits argument continues onto supplementary sheet
Page 30 (booklet p.11)
Page 32 — supplementary answer sheet S1, conclusion
Page 32 (Supplementary sheet S1)

The writing, with corrections marked inline

Legend: red strikethrough = removed  |  green highlight = added or replaced  |  yellow highlight = handwriting unclear
Booklet p.8 (lines 1–21) — opening & thesis
0[No title provided by the student]
1Is it considerable advisable to look for opportunities
2around Asia, amid a shortage of employment
3opportunities in Hong Kong? It is not new to us that Hong Kong,
4as a cosmopolitan city, is a land of vast
5opportunities. Though the authority authorities may boast
6Hong Kong as about Hong Kong being a well-established international
7trading and financial centre, it has nothing
8to do with the fact that graduates of
9the city is are finding employment opportunities
10in the city increasingly curtailed. According
11to a research conducted by the Hong Kong
12University, up to 80% of Rrespondents who are
13graduates see finding a job in Hong Kong as
14an arduous uphill battle. Recently, think-
15tanks have proposed that graduates who
16failed to find a job in Hong Kong could
17look for opportunities in other cities in
18Asia. This became has become a bone of contention and
19has sparked off intense debate. Hereby I would
20like to show my support to I therefore lend my support to the
21suggestion.
Booklet p.9 (lines 22–45) — reason 1: pragmatic & feasible
22First of all, the suggestion is
23pragmatic and feasible. As mentioned above,
24employment opportunities in Hong Kong are shrinking.
25It has become a wishful thinking wishful thinking for university
26graduates, with a degree in hand, to look
27for jobs with bright prospect bright prospects. It is of
28utmost importance to settle the group of
29desperate graduates who failed to find a job
30in Hong Kong, or else it may lead to massive
31wastage of high-skilled labour force. To stem
32graduates’ discontent and utilize the labour
33force, I would regard the suggestion as valid
34and pragmatic. Besides, it is possible for
35Hong Kong graduates to look for jobs around
36Asia. The government has spent billions on the
37education of our younger generation, and thus
38has equipped youngsters with English and Mandarin
39Chinese communication skills. With high proficiency
40in English, I believe most graduates would find
41it easy to communicate with foreigners when they
42work abroad in other Asian cities, as the
43English is one of the global languages. With
44the ability to speak in Mandarin, graduates
45have considerable competitiveness in Chinese
Booklet p.10 (lines 46–69) — reason 2: benefits to graduates
46cities like Shanghai and Beijing. Given that
47it is pragmatic and feasible, why don’t should I
48not show my support to the suggestion?
49 
50Apart from concerns over feasibility, benefits
51that can be gained by graduates by working
52abroad is are also why I support the suggestion.
53In Hong Kong, having a degree is not
54a manifestation of one’s maturity. Our
55education system emphasize emphasizes too much on
56paperwork drilling and textbook knowledge,
57while it has neglected the important skills
58that really makes make a student successful. By
59saying this, I am not actually referring to
60graduates who have fallen prey to our current
61exam-oriented education system, and have
62failed to acquire basic life skills as such as
63communication skills and self-care skills.
64Working in other Asian cities not only could
65allow our graduates to look for jobs, but
66could also force them to shift for themselves fend for themselves
67and acquire the life skills that they should
68have acquired. Could they flex their creativity creative
69muscles to resolve daily problems? Could
Booklet p.11 (lines 70–91) — reason 3: mutual benefits
70they be courageous enough to speak to a
71passerby with a different mother-tongue? These
72real-life experiences could polish their life skills,
73allowing them to allow them to navigate unchartered uncharted waters, and
74sharpen their competitive edge. If one day they
75returned to Hong Kong, what the city could embrace
76would be a group of experienced graduates with
77broad exposure. In view of all the benefits, why
78not the suggestion be supported support the suggestion?
79 
80Last but not least, I support the suggestion
81because it could provide mutual benefits for
82other Asian cities and Hong Kong. Asia is now
83experiencing an economic takeoff, and many
84Asian cities are developing rapidly. Cities
85like Hanoi in Vietnam and Mumbai thirst
86for talents, especially those in the management
87field. By having our graduates to work abroad
88in other cities in Asia, the demand
89could be fulfilled, and which also guarantee this would also guarantee
90a good outlook for graduates who work in
91those cities. On the other hand, having
Booklet p.11 cont. — supplementary bridge (lines 92–103)
92our graduates work abroad could let Hong Kong
93off the hook — to free Hong Kong from the
94looming prospect of an ever-growing young youth
95unemployment rate. Besides, it could also add value
96to the degrees that our graduates are holding.
97Instead of being forced to work in territories
98which our graduates are not acquainted with in
99Hong Kong, they could probably now work under
100their own scope of study abroad. This would
101make their degrees useful and representative, and
102thus enhance their value. It could serve as a
103mean means to promote our local universities abroad in a sense.
Supp. sheet S1 (lines 104–116) — conclusion
104Above are the three reasons that prompted prompt me
105to support the suggestion. In my opinion, it is
106short-sighted to say that by sticking encouraging our
107graduates to work in other Asian cities, we are
108losing our talents and bright minds forever.
109After all, we are living in a globalized era.
110What we give out may return as a group of
111experienced and internationalised labourers in different
112fields. Still, it is imperative that our government
113would review its policies, and ensure that
114sufficient job opportunities have been promised are provided.
115I invite all of you to follow up on this issue, so very
116soon, we will become young graduates of our society.
No title provided. The question explicitly asks for an appropriate title. The student went straight into the opening sentence. This is a small but real content deduction in HKDSE marking.

Continuation on a supplementary answer sheet. The student ran out of space in the main answer book (which ended on page 30 / booklet p.11) and continued the final paragraph + conclusion on Supplementary Answer Sheet A (page 32 of the PDF, labelled S1). The Question No. box on the supplementary sheet correctly shows Q3 ticked. The corrected version above stitches the two pages together. Without the supplementary sheet the article would have appeared to break off mid-sentence at “ever-growing young…”.

Word count note: the full piece (main answer book + supplementary sheet) runs to roughly 700 words — well over the 400-word target. Length is no longer the issue it appeared to be before the supplementary sheet was found, but the article would still benefit from a tightening pass.

Inserted word on page 27: “Amid” appears above the opening line; the student inserted it to make “amid a shortage of employment opportunities”. Kept in the corrected version.

Strengths to praise

1. Strong, audience-aware opening hook

The article opens with a direct rhetorical question (“Is it advisable to look for opportunities around Asia amid a shortage of employment opportunities in Hong Kong?”) and then immediately concedes the broader context (“Hong Kong, as a cosmopolitan city, is a land of vast opportunities”) before introducing the problem. This is exactly the move that opinion-piece writers make: hook, frame, then pivot.

2. Evidence brought in early

The student uses a real-sounding statistic (“up to 80% of respondents who are graduates see finding a job in Hong Kong as an arduous uphill battle”) and names a source (HKU). Whether the figure is exact or not, it gives the argument empirical weight before the opinion arrives.

3. Clean three-pronged argument architecture

The article uses a textbook three-reason structure with clear sign-posting: First of all… (pragmatism / feasibility), Apart from concerns over feasibility… (benefits to graduates), Last but not least… (mutual benefits). Each reason gets its own paragraph and its own example.

4. Specific named examples instead of generalities

The piece names Shanghai, Beijing, Hanoi (Vietnam), Mumbai — not just “other Asian cities.” Specificity is one of the strongest markers of mature argumentative writing.

5. Strong figurative language and idioms

An arduous uphill battle, a bone of contention, sparked off intense debate, fallen prey to, flex their creative muscles, uncharted waters, sharpen their competitive edge, off the hook, looming prospect. These are deployed in their natural collocations — the student has internalised them, not just memorised them.

6. Counter-argument concession built into the case

The middle paragraph briefly concedes that HK education is flawed (“having a degree is not a manifestation of one’s maturity… our education system emphasizes too much on paperwork drilling”) and uses that concession as a springboard for the next argument — graduates need to leave precisely to learn the skills HK didn’t teach them. Sophisticated rhetorical move for a 17-year-old.

Grammar notes

IssueExplanation
(line 9) graduates of the city is findinggraduates of the city are finding Subject-verb agreement. Graduates is plural; the head noun isn’t city. (A common slip when there’s a singular noun nearer the verb.)
(lines 5–6) boast Hong Kong as a…centreboast about Hong Kong being a…centre Boast as a transitive verb (boast a feature) means “have proudly.” It doesn’t take X as Y. The construction wanted here is boast about X being Y, or simpler — tout Hong Kong as….
(line 12) up to 80% of Respondentsup to 80% of respondents No reason to capitalise respondents — it’s a common noun.
(line 25) It has become a wishful thinkingIt has become wishful thinking Wishful thinking is an uncountable phrase (like good news, hard work) and takes no article.
(line 27) jobs with bright prospectjobs with bright prospects In the sense of “future possibilities,” prospects is almost always plural (career prospects, marriage prospects, bright prospects).
(line 87) By having our graduates to work abroadBy having our graduates work abroad The causative pattern have someone do something takes the bare infinitive (no to): have them work, have her sing, have him wait.
(line 89) and which also guaranteeand this would also guarantee Two issues: and which is grammatically clunky (a relative pronoun shouldn’t follow and here), and the verb should agree with the singular subject and use modal would for the hypothetical.
(line 59) I am not actually referring to graduates who have fallen prey The logic of this sentence seems inverted: the surrounding paragraph clearly is about those graduates. Likely intended: “I am actually referring to graduates who have fallen prey…” (drop not).
(line 55) education system emphasizeeducation system emphasizes Subject-verb agreement. System is singular.
(line 58) skills that really makesskills that really make The verb agrees with the plural antecedent skills, not the nearer singular noun.
(line 62) basic life skills as communicationbasic life skills such as communication As alone introduces a role or capacity (works as a doctor); to introduce examples, use such as, like or including.
(line 66) shift for themselvesfend for themselves The fixed idiom is fend for oneself — to look after oneself without help. Shift for oneself exists in older English but is archaic.
(line 73) unchartered watersuncharted waters Common confusion. Uncharted means “not on any map.” Unchartered would mean “without a charter / licence,” which is unrelated to navigation.
(line 68) flex their creativity musclesflex their creative muscles The idiom is flex one’s creative muscles: creative is the adjective. Creativity is a noun and doesn’t modify muscles.
(lines 64–66) Working in other Asian cities not only could allow our graduates… The not only…but also… construction reads more naturally with inverted word order: Not only could working in other Asian cities allow our graduates to look for jobs — it could also force them to fend for themselves.
(line 94) ever-growing young unemployment rateever-growing youth unemployment rate Young is an adjective for people (young people, young workers); the standard collocation for the social-economic indicator is youth unemployment. The student bridged the two pages with young; the correction picks the right form.
(line 103) It could serve as a meana means Means in the sense of “a method or instrument” is always written with the -s, whether singular or plural (a means to an end, by means of, a means of transport). Mean without the -s is the verb or a statistical average.
(line 103) promote our local universities abroad in a sensepromote our local universities abroad In a sense hedges a claim the student has just made positively; it weakens the line. If you mean X, just say X.
(line 104) that prompted me to supportthat prompt me to support The argument is being made in the present (these are the reasons that currently motivate the writer’s position), so the simple present prompt fits better than past prompted.
(lines 112–113) imperative that our government would reviewimperative that our government review After it is imperative / essential / crucial / vital that…, English uses the bare subjunctive form of the verb — no would, no -s. The student crossed out would mid-sentence, sensing the issue.
(line 114) sufficient job opportunities have been promisedare provided / are made available Jobs aren’t promised — promises sit in the mouths of politicians but not in the world of work. Provided, secured, made available, created all carry the meaning the sentence wants.
(lines 115–116) so very soon, we will become young graduates of our society The final line is muddled. The speaker is themselves about to become a young graduate, so the line is meant to call the audience to action while positioning the speaker among them. A cleaner version: “…because very soon, we too will be the young graduates standing in their shoes.” See the professional rewrite below.
Title missing The question explicitly asks for an appropriate title. The student went straight into the opening line. A working title appears at the top of this analysis in square brackets for reference.

Style suggestions (where strong writing could become outstanding)

Categories: Fluency sentence flow, collocations, rhythm.   Authenticity places that sound student-y or translated; how a native voice would say it.   Text-type fit matching the conventions of the genre — here, an argumentative magazine article.
Suggestion 1 · fix the wrong word in the opening
Authenticity line 1
Original: “Is it considerable to look for opportunities around Asia…”
Try: “Is it wise to look for opportunities elsewhere in Asia…” / “Should our graduates look elsewhere in Asia…”
Considerable means “large in size or amount” (a considerable sum, considerable damage). The student wants something like wise, sensible, advisable. This is the most prominent word in the article (it’s the first sentence) and the wrong choice undercuts the rest.
Suggestion 2 · tighten “it is not new to us that”
Text-type fit lines 3–5
Original: “It is not new to us that Hong Kong, as a cosmopolitan city, is a land of vast opportunities.”
Try: “Hong Kong has long prided itself on being a cosmopolitan city — a land of vast opportunities.”
It is not new to us that… is a Hong-Kong-classroom-essay opener. A real opinion piece would simply state the claim with the assumption that readers already know it.
Suggestion 3 · replace “Hereby” with native register
Authenticity lines 19–21
Original: “Hereby I would like to show my support to the suggestion.”
Try: “I support this suggestion — and here is why.” / “I take the view that the suggestion deserves our support.”
Hereby belongs in legal documents (I hereby resign, hereby certify). In an opinion piece, it instantly dates the writer. The thesis is the strongest sentence in any opinion piece — it should sound like the writer wrote it themselves, not a notary.
Suggestion 4 · sharpen “I would regard the suggestion as valid and pragmatic”
Authenticity lines 31–34
Original: “To stem graduates’ discontent and utilize the labour force, I would regard the suggestion as valid and pragmatic.”
Try: “For both reasons — to ease graduates’ frustration and to put their training to use — the suggestion is a sensible one.”
I would regard X as Y is essay-formula English. Native opinion writers state opinions directly: the suggestion is sensible. Utilize the labour force is also management-handbook talk; put their training to use is the human version.
Suggestion 5 · replace “considerable competitiveness” with the natural idiom
Fluency lines 44–46
Original: “graduates have considerable competitiveness in Chinese cities like Shanghai and Beijing”
Try: “graduates would have a real competitive edge in Chinese cities like Shanghai and Beijing”
Considerable competitiveness is a literal translation that no native speaker says. A competitive edge (or a real advantage) is the natural phrase, and the conditional would have matches the hypothetical context.
Suggestion 6 · recast “what the city could embrace would be”
Fluency lines 74–77
Original: “If one day they returned to Hong Kong, what the city could embrace would be a group of experienced graduates with broad exposure.”
Try: “If they ever return to Hong Kong, the city will welcome back a more experienced, more worldly generation.”
The original is a passive, indirect construction (what the city could embrace would be…) that buries the most important word (welcome). Putting the city in the subject position and the graduates in the object position lets the sentence breathe.
Suggestion 7 · turn “thirst for talents” into a more vivid image
Text-type fit lines 84–87
Original: “Cities like Hanoi in Vietnam and Mumbai thirst for talents, especially those in the management field.”
Try: “Cities like Hanoi and Mumbai are desperate for skilled managers — the kind of professional Hong Kong is now producing in surplus.”
Thirst for talents is correct but generic. Adding the second half (the kind of professional Hong Kong is now producing in surplus) creates the bridge between the foreign demand and the local supply — which is the whole point of this paragraph.
Suggestion 8 · sharpen the closing line
Text-type fit lines 115–116
Original: “I invite all of you to follow up on this issue, so very soon, we will become young graduates of our society.”
Try: “I invite all of you to follow up on this issue — because very soon, we too will be the young graduates standing at the same crossroads.”
The student’s instinct in the closing line is right: address the audience, place the speaker among them. But “so very soon, we will become young graduates of our society” is hard to parse on first reading. “We too will be the young graduates standing at the same crossroads” keeps the same idea but lands it cleanly. Closing lines in opinion pieces deserve the most polish.
Professional rewrite — polishing the conclusion (weak moment)

For comparison only, not a correction. The student does land the article (on the supplementary sheet), but the conclusion is the weakest stretch of an otherwise impressive piece — the recap is plain, the counter-argument is rebutted only briefly, the government’s role is tucked in awkwardly, and the final line is muddled. The rewrite shows what a finished, paid columnist would do with the same three ideas in roughly the same word count.

The student’s conclusion (corrected for grammar)

Above are the three reasons that prompt me to support the suggestion. In my opinion, it is short-sighted to say that by encouraging our graduates to work in other Asian cities, we are losing our talents and bright minds forever. After all, we are living in a globalized era. What we give out may return as a group of experienced and internationalised labourers in different fields. Still, it is imperative that our government review its policies, and ensure that sufficient job opportunities are provided. I invite all of you to follow up on this issue, so very soon, we will become young graduates of our society.

Rewritten by a professional columnist

These, then, are the three reasons I lend my support to the suggestion. To dismiss this approach as a “brain drain” is to misread the era we live in. In a globalised world, talent does not leave — it travels. The graduates we send out today will come back to us tomorrow, carrying with them experience and international perspective no Hong Kong classroom could offer.

But the government cannot simply wave them goodbye. It must review its policies and ensure that, when our young people are ready to come home, there are jobs worthy of them.

The rest is up to us — because very soon, we too will be the graduates standing at this same crossroads. Where we choose to start matters less than that we choose, with our eyes open and our ambitions intact.
What the rewrite is doing differently:
  • An elegant inversion of “losing talents.” “Talent does not leave — it travels.” The student’s “losing our talents and bright minds forever” is the cliche; the rewrite reframes it with a five-word epigram that the reader can quote.
  • Three short paragraphs instead of one long one. Each paragraph carries one idea (counter-argument rebuttal → government’s role → call to peers). Opinion pieces benefit from white space in the conclusion.
  • The government gets its own paragraph. The student’s “Still, it is imperative that our government review its policies…” is grafted onto the end of the previous thought. Giving it a paragraph of its own grants the imperative its full weight.
  • A final line that lands. “Where we choose to start matters less than that we choose, with our eyes open and our ambitions intact.” — one sentence, memorable, addresses the audience and the speaker as a single we. The student’s ending (“we will become young graduates of our society”) reaches for this register but fumbles the syntax.
  • Anticipates the strongest counter-argument by name. “To dismiss this approach as a ‘brain drain’…” puts the opponent’s phrase in quotes and addresses it head-on. Opinion writers gain credibility by naming the very objection they’re rebutting.

Vocabulary to notice

Word Definition Usage notes Synonyms / alternatives
cosmopolitan(adj.) including or containing people or elements from many different countries or cultures; familiar with many countries.Used of cities (a cosmopolitan city) and people (cosmopolitan tastes). Positive in both senses.international, multicultural, worldly, urbane
curtailed(v., past) reduced or limited; cut short.Formal. Used of rights, freedoms, opportunities, programmes (budgets were curtailed). Compare with cut (everyday) and truncate (more technical).reduced, restricted, limited, trimmed
arduous(adj.) involving or requiring strenuous effort; difficult and tiring.Pairs with journey, task, climb, process, battle. Stronger than difficult; carries the image of physical effort.strenuous, gruelling, taxing, demanding
think tank(n.) an organisation that performs research and advocacy on policy matters.Two words, no hyphen (older British texts may hyphenate). Common in political and economic journalism.research institute, policy institute, advisory body
bone of contention(idiom) the subject of an ongoing dispute or disagreement.Vivid metaphor (dogs fighting over a bone). Best in argumentative writing about contested issues. Idiomatic; don’t try to extend the bone metaphor further.point of dispute, contentious issue, sticking point
spark off(phrasal v.) to cause something (usually a debate, reaction, or conflict) to start suddenly.Always followed by an event noun: sparked off a debate, sparked off protests, sparked off a controversy.trigger, ignite, set off, provoke
pragmatic(adj.) dealing with things sensibly and realistically; concerned with practical results.Positive word, often contrasted with idealistic, theoretical, dogmatic. A pragmatic approach, a pragmatic solution.practical, realistic, sensible, level-headed
feasible(adj.) possible to do easily or conveniently; practicable.Often paired with plan, suggestion, option, solution. Compare with possible (more general) and viable (capable of working successfully).practicable, viable, workable, achievable
wishful thinking(n., uncountable) the formation of beliefs based on what one wishes rather than what is real or likely.Uncountable — no article. Carries a tone of gentle criticism (just wishful thinking, mere wishful thinking).fantasy, daydreaming, optimistic delusion, pipe dream
utilize(v.) to make practical and effective use of.More formal than use. Common in management and policy writing. British spelling utilise.use, employ, deploy, harness
manifestation(n.) an event, action, or object that clearly shows or embodies something abstract or theoretical.Pair with abstract nouns: a manifestation of power, of grief, of unrest. Slightly formal.expression, display, embodiment, sign
exam-oriented(adj.) focused on examinations as the primary measure of success.Hyphenated. Often used (slightly critically) of East Asian education systems. Compare with results-driven.test-focused, results-driven, examination-centred
fallen prey to(idiom) become a victim of something harmful.Strong verb phrase. Pairs with abstract enemies: fallen prey to scams, to addiction, to propaganda, to the system.become a victim of, succumbed to, been ensnared by
fend for oneself(idiom) to look after and provide for oneself without help.Common across British and American English. Slightly informal but acceptable in opinion writing.look after oneself, manage on one’s own, get by alone
flex one’s (creative) muscles(idiom) to put one’s skill or ability into practice.Can take any modifier: creative muscles, intellectual muscles, political muscles. Creative, not creativity.exercise one’s skills, put one’s abilities to use
uncharted waters(idiom) a situation that is unfamiliar or has not been experienced before.Literally: parts of the sea not on any nautical chart. Spelled uncharted — not unchartered.unfamiliar territory, new ground, terra incognita
competitive edge(n. phrase) a quality or advantage that gives one a superior position over competitors.Business and economic register. Pair with gain, sharpen, lose, maintain.advantage, edge, head start, upper hand
broad exposure(n. phrase) wide experience or contact with many different things, situations, or ideas.Common in CVs and recommendation letters: broad exposure to different markets / cultures / industries.wide experience, varied background, extensive contact
economic takeoff(n. phrase) the stage at which an economy begins rapid, sustained growth.From W. W. Rostow’s stages-of-growth theory (1960). Useful for writing about developing economies.economic boom, surge, lift-off
thirst for(v. + prep.) to have a strong desire for.Used with abstract objects: thirst for knowledge, for power, for revenge, for talent. Slightly literary.crave, hunger for, yearn for, long for
looming prospect(n. phrase) an anticipated event or possibility approaching in a threatening way.Loom as a verb means to appear large and threatening. Looming prospect, looming threat, looming deadline, looming crisis.impending threat, approaching danger, gathering storm
off the hook(idiom) released from blame, responsibility, or an obligation.Originally from fishing. Often used in negotiation or accountability contexts. Watch the tone — can sound a bit casual for a formal article.off the line, in the clear, absolved, released
imperative(adj.) of vital importance; crucial. (Also a noun: an essential or urgent thing.)Followed by that + bare subjunctive (“it is imperative that he be informed”, “it is imperative that we act”) — no would, no -s on the verb.essential, crucial, vital, urgent
globalized / globalised(adj.) shaped by global integration of economies, cultures and societies.British globalised, American globalized. Common in opinion writing about trade, migration, and labour markets. Pair with era, economy, world, workforce.international, transnational, interconnected, borderless
internationalised(adj.) having become international in character; exposed to or shaped by multiple countries.British spelling; American internationalized. Used of people (an internationalised workforce), institutions (an internationalised curriculum), or capital.cosmopolitan, global, multinational, worldly

Comments

Leave a Reply